New West Notes: A PajamasXpress blog from Pajamas Media and Politics Central

August 2007

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  
Bill Bradley

While Biting Villaraigosa, Villines Shows How To Work In A Coalition Government


While Assembly Republican Leader Mike Villines has taken a big bite out of Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s portfolio, he’s also showing how a conservative can work effectively in a mostly Democratic state.

The big cuts in public-transit funding by state lawmakers, sparked by Villines, have a sudden impact on Villaraigosa, who, in his current scandal-struck state, didn’t show up to lobby for his own program. The Legislature stepped into the power vacuum, slashing $336 million earmarked for Los Angeles and imperiling the long-promised Expo Line to the Westside.

The proposed state budget, now weeks past deadline, was approved by the state Assembly with the support of Villaraigosa’s ally and longtime friend Speaker Fabian Núñez of Los Angeles, and aims to take $1.3 billion in gas-tax revenue intended for transit to bail out the state’s general fund.

The loss is a clear setback for Villaraigosa, whose administration is hurtling forward in approving tens of thousands of new units of controversial, dense, high-rise housing in Los Angeles, to be serviced by a now-vanishing state transit budget.

Even before the Assembly raided the gas-tax money, it was being eyed by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, who in May proposed a $1.5 billion gas-tax transfer to the general fund. And the news won’t get better. State Senate Republicans are withholding approval of the budget, demanding $842 million more in cuts. Their leader, Orange County’s Dick Ackerman — who barely held his position even when challenged by the casino tribes’ senator, Jim Battin, who had nothing bad to say about the tribes even during the recall — is being besieged by some of the Republican senators he leads, who are even more conservative than he is. While the spending plan hammered out last month created an aura of compromise, 15 Senate Republicans, led by right-wing maverick Senator Tom McClintock, have refused, so far, to join in the freshly frugal bipartisanship.

After Schwarzenegger proposed raiding the gas tax revenue, Democrats restored the money in their version of the 2007-’08 budget. But with Villaraigosa failing to lobby, there was no hope that the Democrats’ effort would stand. Given the fiscal mood, it is clear that gas tax funding from the state for L.A.’s badly needed Expo Line is dead, at least for now.

Despite the bad news for dramatically more congested L.A., the governator has persuaded the still new, right-wing Assembly Republican leader, Mike Villines of Fresno, to take some moderate steps in other areas. For example, Villines supported billions in bonds for prisons and prison rehab programs, backed a plan to make sure patients with pre-existing conditions aren’t denied health coverage, opposed a move to strip funding for foster children — and even suggested compromise with the Democrats to fix the state’s widely criticized practice of gerrymandering voting districts to protect incumbents.

Schwarzenegger last year described some of his Republican colleagues as “the wild bunch,” but now expresses optimism about his ability to work with Villines and others. And Villines, who heads a Capitol prayer group and was chief of staff to the very conservative Republican Charles Poochigian — who suffered a landslide loss last year to Jerry Brown for California attorney general — recently declared, “We set aside our partisan differences” to agree on a budget.

That budget, if ultimately backed in some form by the California Senate this summer, would whittle the deficit, establish the biggest “rainy day” budget reserve in California history, accelerate the repayment of bonds, make the transfer of $1.3 billion in gas-tax revenues from transit projects like the Expo Line to the general fund, delay for several months a cost-of-living increase for some welfare programs, and preserve public-school and state-university funding.

California is one of only three states requiring a supermajority — two-thirds of the Legislature — to pass a budget, which gives the minority Republicans a major voice. To reach the supermajority, the 48 Democrats in the Assembly and 25 Democrats in the Senate must find eight Sacramento Republicans to agree to their budget — six Republicans in the Assembly and two in the Senate.

Because the Democrats must woo at least some Republicans, it gives minority conservatives unusual influence over California fiscal matters. Nine Republicans, including Villines, voted for the compromise budget in the Assembly. Others backed it in caucus but opted to keep their virginity for the benefit of activists. But so far, on the Senate side in the Capitol, no Republicans have agreed, officially that is, during negotiations to join the Democrats.

Would that Republicans had exercised this sort of discipline when the state got into its fiscal mess in the Gray Davis years. Up until 2002, when the state plunged into its massive deficit, the Republicans were right in there with the Democrats, enacting tax breaks as the Democrats took on new spending commitments.

But this time, Villines insisted that “$1.2 billion in added spending has to come off the table,” almost all of it for programs and projects Democrats were hoping to expand rather than trim. When Villines prevailed, it killed L.A.’s hope for major transit relief.

DESPITE HIS SEVERE FISCAL WHACK at Los Angeles, Villines looks to play an interesting and key role in California politics — as a thorn in the governor’s side but also as a maturing politician able to moderate his right-wing views to make things happen in a non-Republican state.

For example, Villines says he is willing to work with Schwarzenegger to overcome the problem of Californians who are denied health coverage due to pre-existing conditions. He notes that “600,000 Californians fall into that trap” and argues that many of those denied coverage actually have lesser medical issues or illnesses unrelated to their pre-existing conditions that should be covered. “Those with more severe medical issues,” says Villines, should also be covered, “but their inclusion in the insurance pool should be funded by the state.”

One of Schwarzenegger’s key efforts is his expansive health care proposal, which would require most employers to provide health insurance or pay into a state fund, extract “fees” from doctors and medical groups, and force insurers to provide coverage to all Californians.

On redistricting reform, Villines could also play a key role. His version would employ an independent citizens commission to draw new voting districts — to replace the current wildly shaped boundaries that ignore natural geography, city limits and cohesive communities in order to concentrate voters of the same political party. This herding of like-minded voters together, known as gerrymandering, ensures that voting districts in California remain either heavily Democratic or heavily Republican, allowing incumbents to be easily re-elected each time.

Villines is also “open to listening” to some who say the only way to pass redistricting reform is to take Congress out of the equation, since House Speaker Nancy Pelosi threatens a $10 million campaign against altering how the lines are currently drawn.

Villines and Schwarzenegger’s approach — using an independent citizens commission — is more popular in polls than that of Speaker Núñez, who opposes using an independent citizens commission to redraw the lines. His competing reform would use the state’s Little Hoover Commission to draw the districts, but some say watchdog group the Little Hoover Commission is less independent because it is appointed by politicians.

Even as Villines seems ready to mirror California’s more moderate voters’ views, he still seems drawn toward the hardcore partisanship that California voters continually say they do not want.

For example, Villines recently cast a key vote against modernizing Republican politics in California. Reformers inside the party wanted to encourage independent voters — the fastest-growing voter bloc in California. But the California GOP’s executive board voted 11-9 to exclude independent voters from next February’s Republican presidential primary. Villines and Ackerman went along with that restriction, while moderates like Schwarzenegger and former state Republican chairman Duf Sundheim fought it.

As Villines said, “I will frequently have to represent the views of my caucus.” But Sundheim was outraged, saying, “We moved forward, now we’re moving back.” And indeed, Democrats are welcoming California’s unaffiliated voters, known as “decline to state”s, to their own presidential primary next year, hoping to gain their backing later on, in the 2008 general election.

Schwarzenegger increasingly ignores the party per se — which as I’ve noted has generated a big operating deficit in the last several months since its takeover by a hard right faction — and deals with Republicans as he needs to, such as with Villines and Ackerman. This time around, absent lobbying from the suddenly silent Villaraigosa, the deal making resulted in a heavy blow for transit-challenged L.A.

Yet the relative flexibility shown by Villines indicates, at least to some observers, that there is hope yet for a Republican more conventional than the former action superstar to make his mark as a pragmatic problem-solver in Sacramento.

This column has been reworked from my LA Weekly feature.

Your posts are welcome in the Forum.

x

Email this link to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):

Comments (35)

Jonas Blane :

A sane California Republican?

Aug 1, 2007 05:47 AM

Ann :

He's a right winger. But he 's not a crazy right winger.

Aug 1, 2007 06:43 AM

Ann :

When will the budget be finished?

Aug 1, 2007 06:45 AM

Sullihan :

What will come first, the budget or the prison pop cap?

SF Chronicle reports that yesterday the State's request for a stays of the panel to decide a population cap on prisons were denied. And the Panel gave the parties given 15 days to submit their written arguments on how to proceed.

Let me add that the chances for the 9th Circuit or the US Supreme Court or anybody else to halt the Panel are zero.

Aug 1, 2007 07:23 AM

Bill Bradley :

We'll see if federal judges risk the wrath of Californians.

Aug 1, 2007 07:24 AM

Bill Bradley :

Not sure, and compared to the real dramas in the world, this is not much of one.

>Ann :
When will the budget be finished?
Aug 1, 2007 06:45 AM

Aug 1, 2007 07:25 AM

Bill Bradley :

A smart guy, in for the long haul.

>Ann :
He's a right winger. But he 's not a crazy right winger.
Aug 1, 2007 06:43 AM

Aug 1, 2007 07:26 AM

Sullihan :

Let see, in 2002 Judge Reinhardt provided the second vote in a 2-1 decision that was condemned the next day by the United States Senate by the vote of 100 - 0.
And after that same case was tossed by the Supremes (on technical grounds) in the follow up case Judge Karlton ruled the same way as Reinhardt.
Henderson, who has been canonized as a judicial saint in the documentary "Soul of Justice" faced plenty of angry voters in the South as a Justice Dept lawyer in the 60s.
Angry voters are to these three, just a fact of life.

Aug 1, 2007 07:44 AM

Bill Bradley :

Have they released unparoled convicted criminals before?

That would be no.

Aug 1, 2007 07:52 AM

Bill Bradley :

By the way, the LA Times has today "discovered" that the California Republican Party has a giant financial problem.

Aug 1, 2007 07:56 AM

Sullihan :

Bill, they don't have to release anybody, they could just say that the state can't incarcerate new inmates until the population goes way down---which would push the problem onto county jails, which would create its own set of problems.

Aug 1, 2007 08:24 AM

Kandy Kid :

I am glad you presented a more accurate, nuanced view of Villines. He has learned from Plescia’s mistakes and is trying to lead in the world in which he lives instead of the one that he wants to create.

Ann, there will be no budget until the Democrats decide to compromise and eliminate the budget deficit. Finalizing that deal will require the Assembly to return to work, as the GOP will not fall for the “trailer bills to be passed later” scam again. An emergency appropriation could pay all of the service providers that are trying to ratchet up the pressure, but that too would require the Assembly to return.

Politicians abandoning their responsibilities will make great commercials during the term limits extension campaign. Fabian on the French Riviera applying sunscreen while California senior health care clinics close would make a great visual.

Aug 1, 2007 08:52 AM

Sacramento Solon :

KK...

Don't try to place the blame on the Dems for the irresponsible actions of your party. It's beneath you.

Aug 1, 2007 09:08 AM

Kandy Kid :

As you know Solon, it takes two to stalemate. I don't remember any Democratic candidates vowing to support deficit spending for their entire careers. Perhaps that is one of the planks in the Democratic party platform.

Aug 1, 2007 09:21 AM

Sacramento Solon :

KK,

Save the b.s. for someone who believes it. We both know this is more about a leadership fight within the Senate than anything else.

As I said last week, the time to stop playing games is now. Too many little people getting smashed as a few Reep senators play childish games.

Aug 1, 2007 09:28 AM

Bill Bradley :

It's about a number of things. A leadership fight is one of them.

Aug 1, 2007 09:52 AM

Bill Bradley :

President Bush and the Republican Congress certainly had no problem with deficit spending.

They made hash of the Clinton balanced budget, didn't they?

>Kandy Kid :
As you know Solon, it takes two to stalemate. I don't remember any Democratic candidates vowing to support deficit spending for their entire careers. Perhaps that is one of the planks in the Democratic party platform.
Aug 1, 2007 09:21 AM

Aug 1, 2007 09:53 AM

Bill Bradley :

You're welcome.

>Kandy Kid :
I am glad you presented a more accurate, nuanced view of Villines. He has learned from Plescia’s mistakes and is trying to lead in the world in which he lives instead of the one that he wants to create.

Aug 1, 2007 09:55 AM

Bill Bradley :

That wouldn't fool anyone.

>Sullihan :
Bill, they don't have to release anybody, they could just say that the state can't incarcerate new inmates until the population goes way down---which would push the problem onto county jails, which would create its own set of problems.
Aug 1, 2007 08:24 AM

Aug 1, 2007 09:56 AM

Dana :

Last night got a call from a local disability activist organizing a protest this morning at the Governor's Office in downtown L.A. against some of the looming program cuts. I just used a bunch of vacation time yesterday to attend the advisory panel on regional issues I am a member of, so I had to beg off. And while a noble effort I think it is a lost cause.

Even our allies see transit as a safe weakling to rob without consequences. I have started suggesting we advocates caucus after the budget is adopted how we can avoid a similar fate next year. It has happened repeatedly and we have so far been ineffective in mounting a defense that makes the politicos gun shy of us.

Aug 1, 2007 10:12 AM

Capitol Boy :

Viullines is in a lot better shape than Ackerman, that is for sure.

Aug 1, 2007 10:14 AM

Johnnie Rico :

Prayer groups?!

Aug 1, 2007 10:48 AM

Paul Burton :

Until Prop 13 is repealed or modified to raise taxes on corporate property, the California budgeting process will continue to be a shell game - shifting money from one special fund to the general fund or some other special fund. Meanwhile, as the saying goes 'when two elephants (or elephants and asses) fight, the grass gets trampled.' Among those trampled by the lumbering herd of political hacks - the disabled, home health care workers, children, UC Labor Center, educators, people dependent on public transit, etc.

Villaraigosa, like Gavin Newsom in SF, has shown himself to be ineffective and distracted by his personal problems. Hopefully neither one will embarrass themselves further by running for governor, an office they are even more unqualified to hold than our current phony moderate cyborg actor.

Aug 1, 2007 11:12 AM

Dana :

Paul, besides fixing Prop 13 we also need to reform budget process. 2/3 vote requirement for fiscal matters is ridiculous. But I fear these will not be fixed any time soon. Even redistricting reform is no sure thing.

Aug 1, 2007 11:44 AM

NickM :

When Perata pronounced a key part of the Assembly deal DOA in the Senate, of course Republicans were going to demand a budget deal even more to their liking than the one that got 9 Assembly GOP votes. It's standard negotiation theory.

There will be the necessary Aye votes to pass the budget in the Senate from GOPers if Perata takes the Assembly deal up in good faith - trailer bills first.

Perhaps dealing with the FBI investigation is impairing his ability to run the Senate.

Aug 1, 2007 11:53 AM

Vladimir Bierko :

Biting Villariagosa. That would be a great title for docu-drama starring the mayor.

Aug 1, 2007 12:01 PM

Bill Bradley :

More of a nature documentary, I think.

Aug 1, 2007 12:02 PM

Bill Bradley :

Interesting.

>NickM :
When Perata pronounced a key part of the Assembly deal DOA in the Senate, of course Republicans were going to demand a budget deal even more to their liking than the one that got 9 Assembly GOP votes. It's standard negotiation theory.
There will be the necessary Aye votes to pass the budget in the Senate from GOPers if Perata takes the Assembly deal up in good faith - trailer bills first.
Perhaps dealing with the FBI investigation is impairing his ability to run the Senate.
Aug 1, 2007 11:53 AM

Aug 1, 2007 12:03 PM

Bill Bradley :

True.

>Dana :
Paul, besides fixing Prop 13 we also need to reform budget process. 2/3 vote requirement for fiscal matters is ridiculous. But I fear these will not be fixed any time soon. Even redistricting reform is no sure thing.
Aug 1, 2007 11:44 AM

Aug 1, 2007 12:04 PM

Ann :

Maybe we will get a budget tonight.

Aug 1, 2007 01:48 PM

Jonathan Hemlock :

Mr. Villines seems a sensible conservative. I wonder when the Senate's Republicans will have stable leadership.

Aug 1, 2007 05:46 PM

Bryan Williams :

Ridiculous to Democrats, maybe...this is the one chance Republicans have to flex what little power they have in this State...

Dana:
Paul, besides fixing Prop 13 we also need to reform budget process. 2/3 vote requirement for fiscal matters is ridiculous.

Aug 2, 2007 03:33 PM

Bill Bradley :

California is quite an anomaly with the 2/3 requirement. 47 states don't have it.

Using it to affect non-budgetary matters violates the democratic principle of majority rule.

Aug 2, 2007 08:44 PM

Bill Bradley :

There's a deeper question. Why isn't the Republican Party a better and more appealing political party?

Aug 2, 2007 08:45 PM

Bill Bradley :

Incidentally, NWN passed 36,000 comments sometime last week.

Aug 6, 2007 03:34 PM

Comments have been archived for this page.

Support Pajamas Media; Visit Our Advertisers
Support Pajamas Media; Visit Our Advertisers

RSS Feeds

RSS | Atom
ADVERTISEMENT